San Diego Firefighters Sue After Being Forced to March in Gay Pride Parade

[RescueKujo 130]

San Diego Firefighters File Complaint for Being Forced to Attend Gay Pride Parade

Tuesday, August 07, 2007

By Melissa Drosjack

In 28 years of responding to fires and saving lives, Fire Capt. John Ghiotto of the San Diego Fire Department never thought his job would require him to attend a Gay Pride parade.

"I've dealt with finding bodies in burning buildings, traffic accidents with kids, but I've never been so stressed out before until this incident," Ghiotto told FOXNews.com in an exclusive interview.

Ghiotto and three other firefighters filed a sexual harassment complaint against the city's fire department last week after being forced to attend the parade in uniform despite objections they made to superiors.

“I don’t want anybody else to go through this. This is a whole different ball game. I think our officials up above need to look at this,” Ghiotto said.

The firefighters claim parade attendees made obscene gestures, uttered inappropriate remarks and displayed lewd behavior that made them uncomfortable. They also demanded a work environment without discrimination and harassment.

The four men allege they were ordered by a battalion chief to attend last month's parade and feared consequences for failure to do so, since refusing to follow a direct order constitutes disciplinary action.

If the men refused to follow the direct order, they could have been suspended on the spot and stripped of any chance for a promotion, according to their manual, Ghiotto said. It was Ghiotto's first direct order.

Ghiotto, engineer Jason Hewitt and firefighters Chad Allison and Alex Kane filed the complaint, which includes detailed descriptions of their allegations. Their fire station is along the parade route.

“You could not even look at the crowd without getting some type of sexual gesture,” Ghiotto said in the complaint. “The experience left me feeling humiliated, embarrassed and offended by this event.”

San Diego fire chief Tracy Jarman, an open lesbian, said she apologized to the men, according to a statement. Jarman said any kind of sexual harassment is "unacceptable, and is never tolerated" in the department.

"I am deeply concerned and troubled by the allegations that have been made. I take them seriously," Jarman said in a statement.

Jarman said she will order the city’s Equal Employment Investigative Office to review the complaint.

The complaint is the first filed against her department regarding participation in a parade or festival, Jarman said.

Sterling Stires, a senior associate with the Thomas More Law Center, said there was a previous complaint issued by a captain in a different station about being forced to participate in the parade.

One of the four firefighters defended his decision to file the complaint, saying it is a sexual harassment issue.

“This EEO complaint isn’t about homosexuality or gay pride. This has to do with people in the workplace being threatened, sexually harassed, and forced to participate in a parade that isn’t like other parades and the behavior that is demonstrated by the public and some of its participants are what are found to be offensive,” according Hewitt’s statement in the complaint.

Hewitt described what he saw at the parade.

“While I was sitting there waiting for the parade to start, I felt that I was forced against my will to be at the Gay Pride Parade and forced to see men in tight shorts dancing provocatively and other men kissing and hugging wearing sexually suggestive material on T-shirts with writing 'Girth and Mirth,' 'Suit Up Before You Dive In,' according to the complaint.

“I was forced into a situation that would compromise what I hold true and what I believe in, my reputation, my character, my integrity, my morals, and my religion," the complaint says.

The firefighters’ lawyer sent a letter to the state Department of Fair Employment and Housing last week, seeking approval to file a sexual harassment lawsuit against the San Diego Fire-Rescue Department.

“The damage has already been done,” said Brian Rooney, a spokesman and attorney for the Thomas More Law Center, which is representing the firefighters. “By participating in this parade wearing the uniform, the perception is clear that they support this type of parade and that is not what they want to convey to their community, their wives and children and their churches."

The firefighters want a change in policy so other colleagues won’t face the same situation.

Fellow firefighters have commended them for filing the complaint, said Charles LiMandri, the West Coast director of the Thomas More Law Center, a not-for-profit public interest law center, and a San Diego-area attorney.

"They realize that they could be the ones to have to do this. They commended them for their courageous stance," LiMandri said.

[JBE 328]

Wow, this is gonna be interesting. It's not something you see everyday, usually it is someone of the gay persuasion pushing a lawsuit. Maybe this will set a trend. The un-PC crowd will finally win one. Hats off to the FC for actually doing the right thing.

Edited August 7, 2007 by JBE

[Guest alsfirefighter]

I can understand their side of things and I have to say I commend them on their professionalism and neutrality. They vocalized their displeasure in a very professional and constructive manner based on what happened during the parade. Many would just discount going because of the parade theme. Although if it was the St. Patty's day parade I'm sure they wouldn't have minded some of those gestures many of us get from that crowd...lol.

[ex-commish 490]

Wow, this is gonna be interesting. It's not something you see everyday, usually it is someone of the gay persuasion pushing a lawsuit. Maybe this will set a trend. The un-PC crowd will finally win one. Hats off to the FC for actually doing the right thing.

I agree. What is this world coming to??? Forcing people to attend a gay parade??? Has this chief flipped his lid? I hope these guys sue them blind and make an example. Enough of the politicly correct bull s**t.

[JM15 386]

San Diego fire chief Tracy Jarman, an open lesbian, said she apologized to the men, according to a statement.

HFD219 I think that you mean that she has flipped her lid. I also think that this is ridiculous, it will be interesting to see the outcome of this.

[RC2389 0]

If the demonstrations at the parade made the FFs uncomfortable, they should not have had to stay. However...

"I've dealt with finding bodies in burning buildings, traffic accidents with kids, but I've never been so stressed out before until this incident," Ghiotto told FOXNews.com in an exclusive interview.

I don't think that quote is going to be doing them any favors.

[RescueKujo 130]

San Diego fire chief Tracy Jarman, an open lesbian, said she apologized to the men, according to a statement.

HFD219 I think that you mean that she has flipped her lid. I also think that this is ridiculas, it will be interesting to see the outcome of this.

But the Battalion Chief that ordered them to the parade was a man. This is a developing story here, I'm sure more will come out tomorrow.