Having been a Chief for 5 years, I can not even imagine ever making a statement like that. Yes it is always in the back of your mind, but hopefully it wont happen. If this story is accurate, then I think that he should reconsider his position as a leader and turn it in. After a job, if my guys come home in one piece with no injuries, that is a successful job. Proper training, and good gear goes a long way in prevention here. The article says "Borrowed Gear" I can only imagine what shape it was in and how it fit as well. Good luck to the guys in his department and hopefully he will sleep at night after one of his guys gets really burned.