memorymaster

Either or. No two situations are alike. Depending on your resources, extent of fire, exposure problems and a plethora of other things, the decision must be made at the time. I'm not knocking either tactic, but, not to be redundant, what you have on your initial size up will dictate what path to follow.

I think the NYC vehicle (pictured) was an 85 or 86. I drove it once in a snowstorm.

That rig that E. 8 has looks like a 1960 Ward LaFrance "Fire Brand" 1000 gpm pumper. NYC had similar except they had closed cabs.

Chief, may God be with you for a speedy and full recovery. Thank you for all you do!

Rest in peace Rudy. Prayers and condolences to his family, friends and co-workers.