http://www.thejournalnews.com/apps/pbcs.dl.../1076/OPINION03
Closing hospital in Dobbs Ferry will create hardship
By PETER J. ROY
(Original publication: December 4, 2006)
I was greatly disturbed to hear the Commission on Health Care Facilities in the 21st Century's recommendation to close our Community Hospital at Dobbs Ferry. I am a life-long resident of the rivertowns, growing up in Irvington and now residing in Dobbs Ferry. Community Hospital is a vital part of the community; pure numbers, and dollar and cents, cannot be the measures alone in the hospital's importance to the region.
I am a emergency medical technician who "rides" for both the Irvington and Dobbs Ferry Volunteer Ambulance Corps. I am a former captain and line officer in Irvington and currently serving as lieutenant of the Dobbs Ferry Corps. In addition, I am a member of the Irvington Fire Department, where I have also served as an assistant chief and line officer. I have more than 14 years of experience with emergency medical service in the area and cannot overstate the importance of Community Hospital.
The ability to bring non-traumatic medical emergencies to Community Hospital vs. transports to Westchester Medical, or St. John's Riverside or Phelps Memorial is reason alone to keep this facility open. The other facilities, while larger and having additional services, are many times overwhelmed with patients, and depending on the time of day, could be difficult to transport due to traffic conditions. Closure of Community Hospital will tax the surrounding area emergency departments as they will need to absorb the patients that Community Hospital currently handles as well as delay care to patients that are currently served.
What bothers me most is the fact that the commission seems to dismiss the improvements in the financial well being of Community Hospital since its inclusion in the Riverside Health Care System. The partnership with St. John's Riverside Hospital has been an economic success as well as relieved potential overcrowding of St. John's Riverside Hospital that may have occurred if Community Hospital was closed a few years ago. The commission's report itself stated, according to a Thursday article in The Journal News, "There are no efficiencies to be gained and possibly profit to be lost . . ." with the closing of the Community Hospital. The article also noted that "only eight percent of their (Community Hospital) patients are Medicaid patients. It does not cause any real burden to the taxpayers (financially.)"
Health-care costs do need to be examined; there are excesses in the system, and improvements should be made. Yet it is my opinion that the closing of the Community Hospital at Dobbs Ferry is far from an improvement in the well-being of the overall system. Closing it will, in fact, cause greater hardship. We are talking about life-saving, time-sensitive care that this facility offers to the community. It is not in excess, it is necessity.
The writer is NYS EMT-B #192686 and ex-captain of the Irvington Volunteer Ambulance Corps as well as ex-chief of the Irvington Fire Department and lieutenant of the Dobbs Ferry Volunteer Ambulance Corps.